Contender for Creepiest Song 🎃

#1

Happy Halloween, Faithless Street!

Get in here with all the songs that make you think “did I just hear that?” Or “Wait, is this about a school shooting?”

I’ll kick this thread off with two classics with John Fowler “The Collector” vibes.

#2
#3
#4
#5
#6

No, no, this is contender for CREEPIEST songs, not sexiest.

#7

Here comes that shit again…

#8

“Hey little girl is your daddy home?” Talk about power differentials!

#9

It’s creepy as hell.

#10

I call my husband daddy and he’s three years younger than me. He’s the father of our children. Of course, I’m also not letting Bruce in my window for sexual servicing so I don’t know how he actually compares.

#11
#12
#13
#14

More from @DougoBlue … you knocked this out of the park. So creepy.

#15

I love this song.
Definitely creepy.

#16

Absolutely… adjacent vibes:

#17

I always thought this song was scary.

#18
#19
#20